Knitting vs Crochet: Which is Easier? Which is Better?
Ah, the long argued age-old debate: knitting vs crochet. Over the years there have been countless discussions. Often passionate and heated discussions over whether crochet is best or knitting is best but at the end of the day, it all comes down to personal preference.
As with anything in life, there are pros and cons to both crocheting and knitting. In this blog post, I’m going to try to help you figure out which craft is best suited for you. By the time you get to the bottom, you’ll be fully armed to decide if you’d like to learn how to crochet or learn how to knit.
Crochet vs Knitting: Figuring Out Which is Better for YOU!
Below you can read about my personal experience learning how to knit and crochet. First I’m going to outline some of the similarities and differences between crochet and knitting. Like anything else, there are pros and cons to each craft and if you can match those with what you prefer personally, it can give you a great place to start.
What’s the Difference Between Knitting and Crochet?
While knitting and crochet both make items out of yarn, the process, tools and architecture of the stitches are very different.
Crochet uses a single hook to create stitches. The hook creates loops in the yarn that in turn makes a knot, which overall makes a denser, more textured fabric than knit fabric (although there are a few stitches in crochet that can make knit-like material).
Crocheters use hooks instead of needles to make their crochet projects. There are a variety of shapes and sizes of hooks but all of them have a single hook on the end of the tool. Crochet hooks can be made from aluminum, plastic, bamboo or steel.
Crocheters hold their hook in their dominant hand and the yarn in the opposite hand. There aren’t really any different styles of crocheting but there are different ways to hold the crochet hook including the pencil grip and the knife grip.
Generally speaking, crochet also tends to use about 1/3 more yarn than a similar knitting project does.
Knitters use two needles to create stitches with yarn. The knitting pattern you’re working on will determine the size, type and length of needles you’ll use for the project. There are straight needles, circular and double-pointed needles and if you get into knitting, you’ll need to figure out what needles you require for the type of project you’re working on.
Knit fabric has a very different structure than crocheted fabric. Knitting makes a “V” shape in is the most basic form and it tends to be more woven instead of knotted.
Knitter’s hold needles in both hands as well as the yarn in one of their hands. There are a number of styles of knitting so which hand you hold the yarn in depends on the style of knitting you use. For example, knitters can knit in some of the following styles
- English Knitting (also called throwing): Common in the U.K and in North America, this knitting style involves holding the yarn in the dominant hand
- Continental Knitting: Popular in Europe, this style of knitting uses the yarn that is held in the non-dominant hand. Variations of this include Russian and Norwegian Knitting. This is a great style for people who already know how to crochet as the yarn is held in a similar manner in crochet.
- Lever Knitting (also known as Flicking): Rumored to be the fastest knitting method, lever knitting is similar to English Knitting but one needle remains still acting as a lever while the other needle does all the work.
- Portuguese Knitting: This style is particularly novel and knitters hold their yarn around their necks which helps to speed up the knitwork.
- Shetland Knitting: Shetland knitters hold their working needle against their bodies by a belt.
Similarities Between Knitting and Crocheting
Both knitting and crocheting require good hand-eye coordination, the ability to read patterns and handle yarn and tools in both hands.
Both crafts are relatively inexpensive to start as a beginner. All you require is some yarn, a hook or knitting needles, a pattern (which are readily available for free online), some scissors and you’re off to the races.
One of the biggest benefits of both crocheting and knitting is the way that these crafts offer a form of relaxation and movement meditation. Both crafts are well known to help alleviate anxiety and panic disorders.
When it comes down to it, you know yourself better than anyone. It’s not really about which craft is better, it tends to come down to personal preference and what you’re better suited to.
Select crochet if you…
- Prefer being able to quickly and easily fix mistakes
- If you tend to fumble holding many things in your hands at once
- If you like projects that work up quickly
- If you like a thicker, generally denser fabric made in loops
- If being patient isn’t your strong suit
Select knitting if you…
- Prefer smooth fabric that drapes and falls nicely
- You want to buy and use smaller amounts of yarn
- If you mostly want to make garments and accessories
- You are dexterous and prefer working with both your hands at once
- If you’re a patient and methodical person
My personal experience learning how to knit and crochet…
My first foray into the world of needlecraft started with knitting. My earliest memories were trying to balance the yarn and 2 large needles in my hands at the same time. I learned the English style of knitting (also known as throwing) and often found myself resting the needles on my lap to try to make sure I wasn’t dropping them.
The other frustration that I just couldn’t get past was what to do when I made a mistake. When you’re a newbie knitter, a dropped stitch can be your worst nightmare and can take hours to recover from. Most of the time, as long as I wasn’t too far into the project, I’d literally rip the yarn out and start the knitting pattern all over again because it seemed easier in the long run.
After a few modestly successful but frustrating attempts to learn how to knit, I was camping at the beach when I noticed the neighbor in the site next to me quickly making the most incredible hats. We had kids the same age so it was a great opportunity to spark up a conversation and investigate how she was making these incredible masterpieces. The neighbor explained to me that the hats weren’t knit but crocheted. What was this strange but beautiful craft? She was kind enough to offer to teach me how to crochet a hat. Luckily, I had some yarn with me and she lent me hook. What do you know, I breezed through that hat like a master on my very first attempt. I remember thinking, why would anyone knit when they could crochet instead. After that day, I was hooked on crochet and so began a wonderful new journey for me.
Since that day, when I learned how to crochet, I’ve learned a lot of new skills and techniques. I’ve realized how relaxed and zen-like I feel when I crochet. BUT, I also realized that I was starting to drool over the fabric and draping of knitted patterns. While my hands and heart were feeling the pull to knit, my brain kept on reminding me of my less than stellar experiences trying to learn how to knit. The hours of trying to figure out how to fix my mistakes, especially now that when I crochet, if I make a mistake, it’s a simple matter of ripping out the row(s) and then simply starting again.
The urge to knit was too great and eventually, I decided to give it a try. This time I had years of crocheting experience behind me…would it help or hinder my attempts to learn how to knit?
I approached my learning differently this time around and Googled “how to knit for crocheters” and it was the best thing I could have done. It turns out there are many ways of holding the yarn and needles, other than the English style. In fact, I found out that “Continental Knitting” is actually considered a preferred method for crocheters. Hallelujah and eureka, I discovered a big part of the knitting puzzle!
The other huge breakthrough for me was learning about the anatomy of a stitch, stitch orientation and how to visually identify the components of what makes a purl stitch looks different than a knit stitch (which every new knitter should learn to save them hours of frustrations).
I still consider myself somewhat of a knitting newbie but I feel confident enough now to be able to understand the basics, fix common knitting mistakes and create shaping. Now if I can learn how to knit faster, I’ll be an even happier girl – but I’m confident that will happen with more time and practice.
My personal advice on whether you should learn to crochet or knit first
In retrospect and with the benefit of experience, if you haven’t really made up your mind and are on the fence about whether or not to start knitting or crocheting first, I would recommend starting with crochet first. I believe it’s a much easier skill to pick up initially compared to knitting.
For me, I became frustrated with learning to knit when it came to making mistakes. Let’s face it, there are always going to be mistakes in the beginning, however, when you make a mistake in crochet, it’s a much easier process to fix which means much less frustration.
My other revelation about knitting and crocheting is that once you have a handle on crochet, it’s much easier to manage things like tension and holding the yarn and needles when you move over to learning how to knit.
Ultimately though, it’s up to you and really, you can’t go wrong. Both knitting and crocheting are amazing hobbies and something that’s easy to fall in love with. I wish you the best of luck and many happy days ahead while you learn one or both these amazing crafts.
Tips for starting out
A final word on how to get started. I have a couple of tips I’d like to suggest.
- Start by choosing a larger crochet hook and yarn. I would suggest a size 5 bulky weight yarn (something inexpensive that you don’t care very much about) and a size (L) 8.00 mm hook.
- Start by practicing chain after chain. Keep on going until you can make the chains approximately the same size and shape. Once you’re done rip it out.
- Don’t even bother trying to start with a pattern. Instead, create a small swatch, maybe 15-20 chains to start.
- The first stitch you should practice is the single crochet stitch. Practice this for as many rows as it takes to feel comfortable and confident. Then try double crochet stitch and finally the half double crochet stitch.
- Start by choosing large straight needles (8.00mm and up) and an inexpensive size 5 bulky weight yarn.
- Watch some videos on how to cast on. I would suggest this great video from Sheep and Stitch here.
- Watch some videos on the various ways to hold your yarn and needles and figure out which one appeals to you the most – remember, you can try all of the various methods to find out which ones work best for you (I literally spent a month trying all the ways to hold the needles and work the yarn).
- Start by casting on 20 stitches and then knit each row, keeping your yarn tension good. You’re looking for a consistent look in the stitches.
- Once you’re feeling confident with knitting, start a new swatch and do rows of purling until that starts feeling good for you
Ok, that’s all from me! I wish you the best of luck and many happy days ahead while you learn one or both these amazing crafts.